WT

The Hand

1981 · Directed by Oliver Stone

🧘2

Woke Score

59

Critic

🍿60

Audience

Ultra Based

Critics rated this 57 points above its woke score. Among Ultra Based films, this critic score ranks #945 of 1469.

Consciousness MeterUltra Based
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

Jon Lansdale is a comic book artist who loses his right hand in a car accident. The hand was not found at the scene of the accident, but it soon returns by itself to follow Jon around, and murder those who anger him.

Consciousness Assessment

Oliver Stone's 1981 venture into psychological horror presents a film so thoroughly indifferent to contemporary social consciousness that it feels almost archaeological. The narrative concerns itself entirely with male anxiety, marital dissolution, and the monstrous id made manifest through a severed limb. Michael Caine navigates the proceedings with the weary professionalism of a seasoned actor performing what he himself termed a money job, which lends the proceedings an inadvertent honesty about commercial filmmaking's purpose.

The film contains a female character in Andrea Marcovicci, but she exists solely as a vessel for the protagonist's emotional crisis. Her presence registers as an obstacle to his descent into paranoia rather than a character with autonomous concerns. The narrative makes no apparent attempt at representation beyond the casting of whatever actors were available in 1981. Gender dynamics are explored only insofar as they fuel the protagonist's rage and justify his spiral into violence.

This is a film about psychological disintegration and the violence that erupts from masculine ego threatened by loss. It pursues these themes with a kind of B-movie sincerity that precludes any self-aware interrogation of its own premises. The severed hand serves as pure symbol, divorced from any social meaning beyond the personal. We are meant to find the spectacle entertaining, not edifying. In this regard, "The Hand" succeeds admirably.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

59%from 6 reviews
The New York Times80

A suspense-horror film of unusual psychological intelligence and wit.

Vincent CanbyRead Full Review →
The Globe and Mail (Toronto)75

There are some genuinely witty lines, but The Hand is no comedy. In the end, it must rank as one of the more original efforts to find danger in mundane places. [18 May 1981]

Stephen GodfreyRead Full Review →
Newsweek60

The Hand is a moderately frightening, reasonably stylish exercise that ultimately doesn't seem worth the effort. Connoisseurs of schlock shock effects will not be satisfied by its tony illusion/reality games, and those looking for psycho/sexual illuminations will be one step ahead of the Freudian cliches. [27 Apr 1991, p.90]

David AnsenRead Full Review →
Variety40

It’s not a pretty sight.

Staff (Not Credited)Read Full Review →