WT

Jamaica Inn

1939 · Directed by Alfred Hitchcock

🧘4

Woke Score

52

Critic

Ultra Based

Critics rated this 48 points above its woke score. Among Ultra Based films, this critic score ranks #1117 of 1469.

Consciousness MeterUltra Based
Ultra BasedPeak Consciousness
Share this score

Synopsis

In early 19th-century Cornwall, young Mary Yellan travels to live with her aunt and uncle at the remote Jamaica Inn, where she discovers the inn is a front for a violent gang of wreckers who lure ships to their doom along the coast. As she becomes entangled in their crimes, Mary must fight to survive and uncover the truth behind the terror that haunts the moors.

Consciousness Assessment

Jamaica Inn stands as a relic of pre-progressive cinema, a straightforward adventure thriller unconcerned with the cultural consciousness markers that would come to dominate filmmaking decades later. Hitchcock's adaptation of Daphne du Maurier's novel presents a young woman protagonist investigating criminal activity, a conventional choice for adventure fiction of the period that owes nothing to modern sensibilities about gender representation. The film is instead preoccupied with the mechanics of suspense, with matters of shipwrecking, criminal conspiracy, and moral corruption treated as plot devices rather than occasions for social commentary. Charles Laughton's gluttonous squire villain exists to be menacing and scenery-chewing, not to prompt reflection on body image or class struggle. The entirely white cast reflects the production's time and place without irony or contemporary awareness. There is no environmental consciousness, no LGBTQ+ subtext, no neurodivergent representation, no revisionist historical perspective. The film simply tells its story. In terms of progressive cultural markers, Jamaica Inn registers as a complete non-event, which is precisely what we should expect from a 1939 British thriller. It is neither preachy nor preachy about social systems. It is merely a film about criminals and a young woman discovering their secrets. One might call this refreshing or merely unremarkable depending on one's appetite for cultural analysis of period pieces.

Analysis generated by our Consciousness Algorithm

Critic Reviews

52%from 13 reviews
Slant Magazine75

Alfred Hitchcock’s Jamaica Inn would have been better titled The Gangs of Jamaica Inn, since the film is thoroughly concerned with groupings, allegiances, and the ways class standing relates to moral obligation.

Clayton DillardRead Full Review →
The Dissolve70

With Hitchcock halfway out the door, Jamaica Inn could have come across as strictly a work-for-hire gig, but it displays enough Hitchcockery to show he wasn’t as disengaged from the material as he would later claim he was.

Craig J. ClarkRead Full Review →
Variety70

Superb direction, excellent casting, expressive playing and fine production offset an uneven screenplay to make Jamaica Inn a gripping version of the Daphne du Maurier novel.

Staff (Not Credited)Read Full Review →
TV Guide Magazine40

JAMAICA INN had many interesting incidents associated with it. Unfortunately, very little of that interest reached the screen.

Staff (Not Credited)Read Full Review →